I guess I've been thinking about worship a little more than usual, probably because of that article I read about a week ago, and also because my wife is an Artist in Residence at the Duke Youth Academy this summer again, and for the past week and continuing through this week, she'll be attending their worship services and plenary sessions when she can (in addition to leading her own workshops on Art and Theology). She mentioned to me last week about all the "explaining" that is going on before some of the worship services they are doing - each night they worship using the traditions of different denominations.
Lately I've been listening to the radio a bunch and skipping to another station when ever a commercial is played. So throughout the day (while I'm in the car), I'll skip through a bunch of different stations and hear many styles of music. It just so happened that tonight, my station was on Shaw University's channel and I was listening to some jazz - it turned out it was Spyro Gyra, from a new album they have out. I thought it sounded like smooth jazz (not my favorite), but the drummer was playing some interesting stuff. Sort of like Dennis Chambers, channeled through Omar Hakim with a bit of Weckl thrown in - though he never turned the beat around like Weckl, you could sense that he might do that when he plays this song live. And then I thought that most people wouldn't think of Dennis Chambers, they'd think of Carter Beauford, but you can't get to Carter (IMO) without first going through Dennis. (And you can't really get to Dennis without going through Billy Cobham).
My point being, that like a lot of things, drumming styles have evolved over the years, building on the styles and personalities of the musicians who have come before. Which makes me think of Jazz - Modern Jazz. How did we get from New Orleans Dixie (and my lack of Jazz History here will be evident) to Smooth Jazz? Couldn't we have stopped at BeBop? Or let's take Rock Music. First there was the 50's, Chuck Berry and the like, and then The Beatles on up to the present day. (Brandon, feel free to step in here and fill in the gaps.) And crossing the boundaries between these two styles, we have (more or less) Prog Rock: Weather Report, Genesis, Rush, etc.
So now I start thinking about how in many churches, worship has been changing. And I started trying to compare various styles and forms found in worship services to the stylistic changes of Jazz leading into Bebop, to the more electric stuff in the late 60's and 70's, on up to "smooth" jazz. Why did someone try to electrify Jazz, was it because they were trying to be "more relevant" or "reach a larger audience" to try and more or less show "them" that Jazz could be as "cool and hip" as the Modern Rock of the day.
Yeah, I know this is scattershot...I'm not the best at organizing my thoughts, but I thought I'd write down what I could.
So where is Modern Worship at compared to the stages that Jazz went through? Will there ever be a point in worship, where we don't have to state the obvious? That somehow the leaders can trust that the congregation knows the chords and the melody, so well that worship can go places we never thought it could, that worship becomes something more than just a simple chord chart.
Or I guess for that matter, we could use the history of Rock and Roll. You know, what's the modern worship equivalent of Dylan going from Acoustic to Electric? Have we seen something that ground breaking and controversial related to worship? Or the equivalent of the Beatles or Bryan Wilson in the worship scene? Not that there would be a specific person, but more a "movement" - a direction that took place that was different from where worship was before?
I guess it's the evolution of modern worship that I'm considering, when I really think about it. Where is it going, where are we going? What does it all mean? Are we progressing and drawing ourselves closer to God, or are we fooling ourselves as we try new ways and expressions of worship?
Maybe it's not even worth considering or having this discussion...but I sort of started thinking about this earlier and had to write it down...though I could explain it alot better to you in person. (I like to talk with my hands, and I usually can't say EXACTLY what I'm trying to say...) But that's what Blogs are for right? Or maybe that's what this blog is for. Me trying to make sense of it all.